
Manchester United are touring North America without star forward Wayne Rooney, a situation which United struggled in last season against the likes of Chelsea and Bayern Munich. Dimitar Berbatov showed he just wasn’t ready to lead the line by himself. Despite the clear technical ability Berbatov has he has yet to live up to the thirty million pound price tag that was (probably unfairly) attached to him ever since his move from Tottenham to Old Trafford. He has shown flashes, but never maintained consistently good form for a prolonged period and never against the top teams when the pressure is on. Two games into Manchester United’s North American Tour Berbatov is showing a few more flashes of brilliance, but as a United supporter one can only hope that these flashes will turn into something a little more when the real season kicks off.
Last season Dimitar Berbatov started on the bench for most European or big Premier League games, with Sir Alex opting to play Rooney at the top of a 4-5-1. Berbatov would often be brought off the bench, but one thing Berbatov has never been and probably never will be is an impact substitute. Last night in Man. United’s 1-0 win over the Philadelphia Union Berbatov did come off the bench and open the game up for United, but that was a rare circumstance. United will not play many games at that slow of a pace this season, and United will not play many “Philadelphia Unions” this season. Natural finishers like Solskjaer or players with pace and energy like Tevez often make good impact substitutions, whereas slow, methodical players like Berbatov don’t capitalize on the tired opposition they are up against. Berbatov has been misused as a substitute many times in the past, but he just is not suited for the role.
The next way Berbatov has been used is in a 4-4-2, a system which Berbatov was more successful in last season. When Berbatov is playing with another forward he is given the chance to hold the ball up, lay it off to the other forward and help be a part of the build up. The problem is Manchester United’s 4-4-2 is a lot faster, and relies more on quick counter attacks than the one Berbatov played in with Robbie Keane at Spurs. Berbatov is not a fast player, he often slows down the United attacks when he holds up the ball. Sure his first touch and skill on the ball is incredible, but when he slows the play down the entire United attack stops functioning. Wayne Rooney, Nani, Antonio Valencia, Ryan Giggs all of these players are forward thinking players who like to get the ball into the attacking third quickly. So although Berbatov’s goal scoring record with United playing in a 4-4-2 last season was good, there is an argument there that he hurt Manchester United’s attack.
The final way Berbatov has been used at United and by far the least effective is as the lone striker in a 4-5-1. Last season was all about Rooney’s 4-5-1 which was fast, effective and used a lot of width. In comparison when Berbatov led the line a 4-5-1, the attack slowed right down, the wingers were forced to cut in to pick up the ball making it look more like a 4-3-3 and very few goals were scored with Berbatov in the 4-5-1.
Based on the evidence above and the evidence we’ve seen from Berbatov on the pitch he is not really a Manchester United player. The type of player Sir Alex was trying to buy when he bought Berbatov, a player who would bring the best out of Rooney, was clearly not the player Sir Alex got. With all that being said though, United have Berbatov who is an incredible talent so not to find a way to use him would be a waster.
Against Celtic in Toronto, Berbatov looked good playing in a 4-4-2 with the young forward Mame Birame Diouf. Diouf did most of the running and pressuring while Berbatov got into advanced positions in the attacking third and spread the ball out effectively. He also find himself with space in the box on several opportunities and one of these chances led to a well taken goal. United supporters will remember the old Wayne Rooney who would never stop running and would often run so much he would get lost in the big games, this is not a Rooney that United supporters want to see again. It is alright for Diouf to play a role that helps free up Berbatov, but Sir Alex will not want Wayne Rooney to sacrifice himself as a major goal scoring threat to help give Berbatov the space and chances he needs.
However using three players to help open up space for Berbatov might work, especially in European competitions where the games are tighter. This World Cup we saw the 4-2-3-1 on display with three of the semi-finalists in Spain, Germany and the Netherlands all employing a 4-2-3-1. At times last season Manchester United’s 4-5-1 looked a bit like a 4-2-3-1 with a player like Ji-Sung Park as the player “in the hole” (the centre forward/midfielder in the 3). This is where Berbatov could be effective. If the two wingers in the attacking three stay wide keeping their men to the outside and Rooney could continue to pressure higher up the pitch there could be a big hole in the middle for Berbatov to show his magic. With Berbatov a little further back and not at the highest level of the attack, Berbatov holding the ball would not slow down the attack, because the two wingers and Rooney would still be running forward. It would then be the job of either Berbatov or the two central midfielders to get the ball forward to them. This gives Berbatov his space while not compromising the pace of attack at all.
Dimitar Berbatov has proved to the Manchester United supporters that he is a talented striker and he could be effective the question is just how. Above is one idea of what must be hundreds running through Sir Alex’s head. However casting Berbatov aside entirely would surely be a waste.